Uchikura & Co., LLC

Many Think Japan's Samurai Era Was Anti-Gay and Anti-Lesbian. History Tells a More Complicated Story.

Many people assume that samurai-era Japan was hostile toward gay and lesbian people simply because it was a traditional society. Surprisingly, the historical record paints a much more complex picture.

 

During Japan's Edo Period (1603–1868), there was no concept of being "gay" or "straight" in the modern sense. Society generally focused more on a person's role within the family and community than on their sexual identity.

 

Male same-sex relationships were well documented, particularly among samurai, Buddhist monks, and even some merchants. One tradition, known as wakashudō ("the way of youths"), described relationships between an adult man and an adolescent male. These relationships often included mentorship and, in some cases, romantic or sexual elements. They were not necessarily viewed as incompatible with marriage, and many men later married women and raised families.

 

The famous Kabuki theater also reflected this culture. Young male actors who specialized in female roles (onnagata) attracted admirers of both sexes, and this became a recognizable part of Edo urban life.

 

Historical evidence for lesbian relationships is more limited, largely because women left fewer written records. However, literature and diaries indicate that romantic relationships between women also existed.

 

Perhaps the most surprising fact is that the Tokugawa government did not generally criminalize consensual same-sex relationships. Authorities were far more concerned with maintaining public order, regulating prostitution, and preserving family responsibilities than policing private relationships.

 

This does not mean Edo Japan was a modern LGBTQ-friendly society. People were still expected to marry, have children, and fulfill their obligations to their family and social class. But compared with many parts of Europe during the same period—where same-sex acts could lead to imprisonment or even execution—Japan's approach was notably different.

 

History is rarely as simple as modern stereotypes suggest. Edo Japan was neither fully accepting nor broadly persecuting. Instead, it followed its own social norms, which differed significantly from those of the West.